Writing on Air

Writing on Air by Jim Paredes


A small voice whispering

Posted on January 27, 2008 by jimparedes

 

At the on-set of the first Iraq war under the American leadership of George Bush Sr., I remember watching TV and seeing US General Norman Schwarzkopf bragging about the superiority of American might against the Iraqis, who had invaded Kuwait. He talked about the armory at his disposal. Like a little boy thrilled with his dazzling new gadgets, he was showing the world how powerful his killing toys were.

During one press briefing, he showed a video of a target-seeking missile that had been launched from a US plane as it hit a truck crossing a bridge. The footage taken from the plane was not as clear or as dramatic a depiction as a Hollywood movie would have been. It was grainy, in black and white and had no sound. It was actually quite clinical. No one seemed to suffer — not even the faceless “enemy” since we did not even really see the man driving the truck.

During the start of the second Gulf War (this time in Iraq, and this time under the command of son George W. Bush), we saw similar scenes again, this time depicted with heightened drama. They called the bombing of the populated city of Baghdad “Operation Shock and Awe.” I wondered then if it was just me or was there the same gleam in the eyes of US Secretary Donald Rumsfeld when he talked about the precision of an aerial attack on Iraq during a press conference.

The way that weapons of war have evolved is quite interesting and terrifying. They now pack more bang per buck and destroy infinitely more lives and property at a much faster rate than at any time in man’s history. And to make it easier for those who use the weapons, they have made the whole process “cleaner.” One does not have to meet, touch or have any contact with the enemy in any way. No more hand-to-hand combat where the possibility of having to face the enemy and see the humanity in his eyes can happen. That’s just too messy. After all, death and suffering are easier to deal with when you can’t hear the screaming. Firepower and the roar of planes can pretty much drown out anything. Besides, they don’t call it “death” now but “collateral damage.” Technology has made it easier for human beings to momentarily stop being human and instead become objective killing machines.

I’ve often wondered what it is like for a Stealth fighter pilot, secure in his cockpit and feeling superior with all his state-of-the-art armory and death gadgets, to push a button and cause the annihilation of a person, a crowd, a village. Sure, one can always avoid any guilt or wash one’s hands by saying that one is just following orders, or just doing a job, even if, at times, he ends up killing innocent children, even fellow soldiers.

But there has to be a little voice sounding somewhere in the core of his being that tells him something else — however subtle, muted or inarticulate the voice may be.

“My God, what have we done?” These were reportedly the words uttered by Robert Lewis, the co-pilot of the Enola Gay, the B-29 that dropped the first atomic bomb on Hiroshima on August 6, 1945. On the other hand, the main pilot, Paul Tibbets, offered no regrets decades later over his role in the atomic carnage.

The act of killing, maiming, torturing or even humiliating a person necessarily involves a “distancing” to allow us to treat the “other” as an object. It is a twisted objectivity that dismisses the reality of other people completely. It’s a mindset one enters into to be able to deny another person’s humanity, and perhaps denying one’s own humanity.

Where peace, harmony and brotherhood are all about oneness, unity and commonality, what is being emphasized when one is at war is the differences — cultural, ideological, political, religious and even physical appearance. And these differences, in the hands of demagogues, can make many people deaf to the little voice that is in tune with what’s real.

And yet, I feel that in many instances, this same objectivity or distancing that we use for bad may also be a powerful tool in bringing us back from hate and restoring us to humanity. Why? Because with distance, we are able to get out of the trance of the craziness, aggression and threat that becomes so compelling with proximity.

The song From a Distance has a line that goes,

From a distance you look like my friend,

Even though we are at war;

From a distance I just cannot comprehend

What all this fighting is for…

I have never experienced war firsthand, not as a combatant, not even as an ordinary person in a war setting. I hope I never have to. I doubt that I am capable of ever killing anyone.

A few days ago, I saw an interview with Osama Bin Laden’s son on CNN. I learned that this handsome man who was a member of Al Qaeda but quit sometime before 9/11 because he disagreed with the way his father was conducting his war, is projecting himself now as a man of peace. Curiously, he said he was organizing a horse race that was meant to promote peace among people.

Interestingly, when asked whether he considered his father to be a terrorist, he said “No.” He said that Osama allowed him to leave the terrorist group and go his own way. For both father and son, the decision they arrived at must have been hard and soul-wrenching, considering their culture of extremism. I am inclined to believe it must have been well thought-out.

I sometimes wonder why I choose to be objective concerning some issues and subjective with others. Many times, it’s a “mind versus heart: thing when we make choices in our own lives. But I suspect that, more often, it’s really more about not making conscious choices either way. We simply make decisions without knowing where we are coming from.

A set criterion for deciding how subjective or objective to be in a given situation is not easy to formulate. Sometimes, one must choose to ignore the forest for one single tree. At times, it’s the opposite. In my case, I believe that any decision that will ultimately create more spaciousness, freedom and well-being for everyone involved is a good guide. In other words, whatever decision will make everyone more human is the correct one. Whatever creates the opposite effect is the wrong decision. And in instances when the din of craziness seems to distort perceptions and drown out reason,  catching the sound of a small voice whispering can spell the difference.

* * *

Are you ready to really feel alive?

“Tapping the Creative Universe,” the cutting-edge creativity workshop, will have a new run in Manila. It’s held March 10-14, and concludes March 17, from 7 to 9 p.m. at 113 B. Gonzales, Loyola Heights, QC. The workshop will cost P5,000.

If you wish to reserve a slot, call 426-5375 or 0917-8554303 and ask for Ollie. If you want to know more about the workshop or would like a syllabus, write to emailjimp@gmail.com.

Don’t wait too long. Seats are limited.

4 to “A small voice whispering”

  1. Bon says:

    A thoughtful piece, Jim. You mention a “culture of extermism”. Don’t you think that the culture that produced the Enola Gay, that decimates people via remote control as you have described, is itself a culture of extremism?

  2. jimparedes says:

    Absolutely. And so it goes with the Iraq war.

  3. ebudae88 says:

    this reminds me of a study by Zimbardo and the Stanford Prison Experiment. which brings me again to think about the classic debate on the nature of man. it is easy for us, individuals, to think and measure our actions whether they’re good or bad based on our own spheres but it seems that when it comes to a larger sphere i.e. in the context of states the easy measurement of what is evil and what is good becomes rather hard. maybe this explains why states could easily go into war because the idea of humanity’s existence is dissolved by the salient need for power and survival. just maybe, the idea of man being inherently good is not to be disputed, but the idea of states being inherently good is a totally different matter to speak of. . .Good day!

  4. TK says:

    I remember that press briefing about the truck that sped through the bridge just seconds before it was hit by a smart bomb. I think Norman said, “now we will show you the luckiest truck driver in Baghdad last night” before showing the film clip. everybody in the room laughed.

    I was thinking, “and how many were not as lucky last night?”



Leave a Reply


  • July 2019
    M T W T F S S
    « Jun    
    1234567
    891011121314
    15161718192021
    22232425262728
    293031  


↑ Top